Is it safe to travel to the United States? Many UvA researchers have been grappling with this question since the Trump administration amended the laws and several foreign researchers were denied entry at the border. “I have decided to stay on the side of caution and will not attend the conference.”
Since the Trump administration’s policy change, scientists have been uncertain about travelling to the United States. In recent months, stricter controls have been introduced and several foreign researchers among who a French researcher were turned away at the border because they had expressed personal criticism of Trump’s policies.
Many UvA researchers are unsure whether it is safe for them to travel to the US for a research visit or conference. The concerns are particularly acute among researchers working in fields that Trump’s policies oppose, such as LGBTQI, climate change and research into misinformation and disinformation. But scientists who have been critical of Trump or spoken out about the war in Gaza are also having second thoughts.
The UvA is following the travel advice issued by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, which was still code green on 30 April. However, the ministry explicitly warns members of the LGBTIQ+ community that different laws apply to them in the United States than in the Netherlands. For example, as of 25 January, the American authorities only accept the gender designation M or F. The UvA provides its employees with additional information via the Intranet, such as the fact that the American authorities may check your electronic devices and social media during the visa application process, upon arrival in the US or at other times during the immigration process.
It is difficult to say how many researchers it concerns. The spokesperson for the University of Amsterdam says they have no insight into this because it is “an individual decision whether to go, not to go or to postpone”. Recently, the travel industry organisation ANVR reported that the number of Dutch people booking a trip to the United States in March is thirty percent lower than in March last year. However, according to the ANVR, this is more likely due to the more expensive dollar than the unrest.
Pulling the plug
For Henny Bos, UvA professor of Sexual and Gender Diversity in Families and Youth, her research into LGBTIQ+ people is the reason why she fears being detained at customs. “The main reason I have doubts is because I am involved in a large American study that has been following children of lesbian parents for years. At the beginning of August, I was supposed to present the research results at the American Psychological Association (APA) conference in Denver, Colorado.” She does not yet know whether she will go.
Her colleagues are also unsure whether they should attend conferences in the United States. PhD student Sanne Agterberg cancelled her participation in a conference in Minneapolis. She is doing her PhD on surrogacy and was supposed to present her research at the Society for Research in Child Development conference in Minneapolis, Minnesota, in early May. “I’m researching what parents of surrogacy need. These can be all kinds of parents, heterosexual couples, but also cisgender gay couples or trans women. If you Google my name, you immediately come across an article about the acceptance of surrogacy in the Netherlands for different types of families. Trump’s policy is anti-transgender.”
Another factor for Agterberg was that she was going to travel to the United States with her mother to take a road trip together. “I had already booked all the flights and accommodation. No one at the University of Amsterdam could reassure me that everything would be okay. At the beginning of April, I pulled the plug because I could still get some of my money back through the travel agency. I rebooked my flights to Europe.” And that’s a shame, says Agterberg. “It’s a missed opportunity to learn more about my field of research and to network. There is no online option.”
Boycott
The decision to go or not is not only based on personal safety, but also on the purpose of the research. Bos: “A colleague from the US with whom I work says that we should boycott the country and show our support for the LGBTQ+ community by not attending the conference. I also think we should take a principled stand, but on the other hand, the APA conference specifically calls for attention to diversity and inclusion, and hopefully this year they will also take a stand in the discussion about policy in the US. Ultimately, it’s about my research target group, who are also coming to the conference. Our knowledge of this group is already so limited, and measures like this will make it even harder for us to learn more about them.”
Surreal
Former UvA student Natalie* did make the trip to the US in April, but not without taking a series of precautions. “I have made public statements critical of the US in the past, so I Googled myself and took some of the sources offline.” This included an article in Folia in which the former student expressed her criticism and which the editors agreed to take offline during her time in the US. She also set all her social media accounts to private and left her personal mobile phone at home.
Natalie made sure that she had all the documents showing that she was in the US for a short time and for business reasons – including her return flight ticket – with her during her trip. “And look up the phone numbers you can call in advance, such as the consulate, the Dutch embassy or your university, in case you are separated from the group,” she advises.
In the end, it wasn’t necessary for her trip. ‘It wasn’t as bad as we thought,” she says now that she’s back in the Netherlands. “We were so anxious that we had prepared for the worst. I’ve never seen it so quiet at the airport. I was the first one at customs and no one asked me anything. Before I knew it, I was already at the baggage carousel. It was surreal.”
Nevertheless, she would prepare just as thoroughly if she were to travel to the US again in the future. It also helped that Natalie was able to travel for her work. “I wouldn’t travel to the US on my personal passport for the time being. It’s clear from my social media that I don’t support Trump and Musk, and you hear stories of people being interrogated for hours for that reason.”
With a few exceptions where foreigners were detained by the American authorities, they are put back on the plane. But even that is not without consequences, according to a UvA researcher who wishes to remain anonymous for privacy reasons. When applying for a visa in the future, applicants must also state whether they have previously been denied entry to the country.
“I don’t want to rule out the possibility of travelling to the US in the future,” says the UvA researcher. “And I’m afraid that what happens under this administration will also influence what happens under future administrations. That’s why I’m opting for safety and not going to the conference, even though I’ll miss working with my colleagues.”
*This name has been changed for privacy reasons. Natalie’s real name is known to the editors.