Last week’s global outage at Microsoft once again highlighted our dependence on American Big Tech. Can universities really manage without Microsoft? A survey at the UvA in five questions. “Being independent of Big Tech should be as natural as brushing your teeth.”
“If Microsoft goes down, the entire UvA can go home,” Natali Helberger, Professor of Law and Digital Technology at the UvA, warned in an interview with Folia last year. “We are almost 90 per cent dependent on a single major US technology provider.”
Tom Hoven, spokesperson for SURF, the IT cooperative for the education sector, is reluctant to put a figure on it. But he agrees that most office software comes from the US. “Universities are no different in that respect from the average company.” At the UvA, teaching also relies on Canvas, a digital learning environment developed by the US company Instructure.
Not every dependency is necessarily a problem, however, Hoven says. “If Teams goes down, you can still use Zoom, although that’s another US company. And if OneDrive doesn’t work, you can store files on SURFdrive. So there are alternatives.”
It has developed gradually. In the 1950s, every university had its own computing centre. “Computers were once developed at universities,” explains Niels ten Oever, Assistant Professor of European Studies, whose research focuses on how norms and values become embedded in communications infrastructure. “Later, development moved into company basements, and eventually into the cloud.”
In Europe, too, the debate on dependence on Big Tech has gained momentum in recent years. Last summer, the European Commission (EC) put forward a plan to increase Europe’s digital autonomy. This is because 70 per cent of cloud services in Europe are controlled by American tech giants.
UvA researchers responded critically to that plan. The rules the EC intends to introduce for the procurement of cloud services by public authorities actually make it more difficult to choose European alternatives, says UvA researcher Kristina Irion. The researchers are also concerned about the expansion of data centres at the expense of sustainability. Over the next five to seven years, the EC aims to triple data centre capacity in the EU.
In 1993, SURF – then an abbreviation for Samenwerkende Universitaire Rekenfaciliteiten (Cooperating University Computing Facilities) – signed what was, at the time, its largest-ever licensing agreement with US software giant Microsoft. Since then, all Dutch higher education institutions have been able to use its services.
According to Hoven, dependence has increased largely because of the enormous expansion of the digital world over recent decades. “Education and research have become much more digital.” Whereas Microsoft used to supply only operating systems and email programmes, its portfolio now also includes Teams, OneDrive and Microsoft Copilot.
Political developments in the US have brought dependence on American Big Tech under increasing scrutiny in recent years. Dutch universities, too, have been jolted into action. One trigger was the loss of access to his Outlook account by a prosecutor at the International Criminal Court in The Hague following sanctions imposed by President Trump. Since then, digital sovereignty has risen to the top of the agenda at Dutch universities.
“If one of our suppliers were to shut us out as a result of political pressure, it would have a major impact on the services we provide,” says Frank van Tatenhove, Senior Policy Officer for Information Management at the UvA. For universities, the implications for academic freedom and data security could be considerable.
Absolutely, says Ten Oever. “The UvA has its IT infrastructure in very good shape: there are around 400 IT professionals working at the Bijlmerdreef. And SURF, the IT cooperative for the education sector, is world-class.” The capacity is there; what is needed is a different set of choices, he argues. “In the past, Big Tech was chosen for convenience. We can make different choices now.”
Hoven also believes it is possible. “Look, if Microsoft were to be unavailable for a year, universities wouldn’t simply close down. You would find another solution, although it would obviously cause considerable disruption.”
Ten Oever makes a similar point. Research shows that people in the Netherlands want digital autonomy, but that this rarely translates into concrete action. “Citizens want the government to sort it out, while the government looks to the market. But that’s not how digital sovereignty works. Nobody else can organise it for you; you have to do it yourself. Just like brushing your teeth or going to the gym, it isn’t always enjoyable, but it’s part of the deal.”
According to Van Tatenhove, complete autonomy is not the objective. The priority, he says, is to “shape education and research on our own terms, free from unwanted dependencies on external parties and resilient in the face of changing external circumstances”. “The UvA still needs to decide where, how much and when we want to reduce our dependencies.”
For Hoven, the main issue is determining which dependencies are “problematic”. “That’s something we’re working on at SURF, too. Which things would you want to replace? Big Tech is now often fully integrated into university systems, and ideally you would want to disentangle that. Another key question is: if you move away from one provider, what do you move to?”
One step the UvA has already taken was the launch of UvA AI Chat earlier this year, its own alternative to ChatGPT. Van Tatenhove explains: “This gives us an environment in which the UvA itself determines how and where data are stored and processed.”
SURF also launched a pilot earlier this year with German software provider Nextcloud, an open-source alternative to Microsoft’s office software. The pilot now involves 2,500 participants from 32 institutions, including twelve universities, as well as universities of applied sciences, vocational education institutions and SURF itself. One of the questions being explored is how Nextcloud could be used for services such as file storage and video calls.
“So far, the experience has been that working with files and making video calls both work well and smoothly,” says Van Tatenhove. “Sometimes the experience is slightly different – buttons may be in different places, for example – but participants say that’s something you can get used to.”
The pilot will run until the end of 2027. If it proves successful, SURF may begin offering the software under the name SURFworks. In the coming months, SURF will hold discussions with institutions to determine what the service should look like.
Those unwilling to wait can already find ways to avoid Microsoft. “I use the Linux operating system, the Zotero reference manager and LibreOffice software,” says Ten Oever. “Most of the world’s software is open source.” Admittedly, that can sometimes be messy. “But that’s life. The idea that the digital world should be a sleek, polished Apple Store is a lie.”